Finding the Right Renters, Faster

Finding reliable tenants quickly is crucial for maximizing your rental income and minimizing vacancies. Thorough tenant screening helps mitigate risks and ensures positive landlord-tenant relationships. This listicle presents eight top-rated tenant screening software solutions for 2026, helping property managers and landlords like you find the perfect fit. We'll cover key features, pricing, and pros and cons of options like Showdigs, AppFolio, and TransUnion SmartMove, empowering you to choose the best tenant screening software for your portfolio. Quickly compare tools like RentPrep, Avail, TurboTenant, Rently, LeHub, Zillow Rental Manager, and Tenant Turner to streamline your tenant selection process.

Key Takeaways

• Showdigs leads with built-in HUD compliance - Automated Fair Housing compliance eliminates regulatory risk across all screening workflows
• AppFolio offers enterprise-grade AI screening - Best for portfolios 50+ units needing comprehensive property management integration
• Compliance is critical in 2026 - Platforms without built-in Fair Housing protections create legal liability
• Variable pricing models are risky - Avoid per-usage charges (like Tenant Turner) that create unpredictable monthly costs
• Screening depth varies significantly - Dedicated platforms offer more robust verification than basic all-in-one solutions

‍

1. Showdigs

Showdigs distinguishes itself from typical tenant screening software by offering a comprehensive AI-powered leasing automation platform. Designed specifically for single-family property managers, it streamlines the entire rental process, from initial listing and scheduling showings to tenant pre-screening and follow-up communication. This comprehensive approach reduces vacancy times and minimizes the administrative burden on property managers, allowing them to focus on scaling their business. Showdigs excels in automating key processes, freeing up property managers to handle more strategic tasks. Its focus extends beyond simple tenant screening to encompass the full leasing lifecycle.

Showdigs offers flexible showing options, including in-person, virtual, and self-scheduled tours. In select markets, they also provide on-demand agent services, handling showings professionally. This flexibility caters to the diverse needs of today's renters and provides property managers with options to optimize their showing processes. Seamless integration with industry-standard property management software like Appfolio and Yardi further simplifies workflows and eliminates data silos. This integration makes it easy to incorporate Showdigs into existing property management systems.

For property managers juggling multiple properties, the platform's automation features translate to significant time savings, allowing them to manage larger portfolios effectively. Positive testimonials from industry professionals highlight Showdigs' positive impact on portfolio size and tenant quality. Furthermore, their customer support team is highly regarded for responsiveness and proactive communication, ensuring a smooth onboarding experience and ongoing support.

HUD Compliance Built-In: Showdigs has Fair Housing and HUD compliance built directly into the platform, ensuring that your screening processes meet federal requirements without additional oversight. This automated compliance reduces legal risk and ensures consistent, non-discriminatory screening practices across your entire portfolio—a critical advantage as regulatory scrutiny increases in 2025. Unlike platforms that require additional compliance oversight, Showdigs' built-in protections give property managers peace of mind that every screening follows federal guidelines automatically.

Pros:

• Comprehensive automation of the entire leasing funnel reduces vacancy durations and administrative workload.
• Flexible showing options: in-person, virtual, self-scheduled tours, and professional on-demand agent showings (in select markets).
• HUD compliance built-in - automated Fair Housing compliance across all screening processes.
• Seamless integration with Appfolio and Yardi simplifies operational workflows.
• Proven to increase portfolio size per manager and improve tenant quality.
• High-quality customer support.

‍

Website: https://showdigs.com

Showdigs earns the #1 spot on this list because it goes beyond basic tenant screening software by automating the entire leasing process with built-in HUD compliance. Its focus on single-family property management, combined with AI-powered features, automated Fair Housing protections, and flexible showing options, makes it the strongest contender for property managers seeking to scale their operations efficiently, improve tenant quality, and maintain regulatory compliance. While the pricing model and agent network coverage should be considered, the platform offers a compelling solution for those managing a larger number of units and looking for a comprehensive, technology-driven, and legally compliant approach to leasing.

2. AppFolio

AppFolio earns the #2 spot as a comprehensive tenant screening and property management solution designed for professional property managers with larger portfolios. While it requires a higher investment than standalone screening tools, its enterprise-grade features, AI-powered recommendations, and deep integration capabilities make it a powerful choice for property management companies managing 50+ units. The platform combines robust screening with full-spectrum property management tools, creating operational efficiency that justifies its premium positioning.

AppFolio goes beyond basic screening by offering a comprehensive suite of property management tools, making it a one-stop shop for everything from tenant applications and screenings to accounting and maintenance. This enterprise-grade platform provides in-depth credit, criminal, and eviction reports, combined with income verification, empowering property managers to make informed decisions. Its advanced features, like AI-powered screening recommendations and global watchlist monitoring, contribute to more efficient and secure tenant selection.

For property management companies dealing with a high volume of applications, AppFolio streamlines the entire tenant screening process. Imagine automating the screening of dozens of applicants against customized criteria, receiving AI-driven recommendations, and seamlessly integrating the results into your existing property management workflow. This efficiency translates into significant time savings and reduces the risk of human error. Larger landlords and tenant placement companies also benefit from the comprehensive nature of AppFolio, centralizing all tenant-related information in one secure platform. Features like identity verification with fraud detection add an extra layer of security, protecting your investments from potential risks.

AppFolio truly shines with its integration capabilities. The platform seamlessly blends tenant screening with other essential property management functions, such as accounting, maintenance, leasing, and communication tools. This cohesive ecosystem simplifies operations and allows for better data management across all aspects of your business. For instance, you can easily track applicant progress, communicate with potential tenants, and manage lease agreements, all within the same platform. If you're already using Showdigs, you can leverage their integration with AppFolio to streamline your leasing process even further. Learn more about AppFolio.

While AppFolio's pricing isn't publicly available, it's important to note that its enterprise-level features come with a higher cost structure than simpler tenant screening software. It typically requires a minimum of 50 units, making it less suitable for individual landlords with only a few properties. The platform also has a steeper learning curve due to its extensive features, which might require dedicated training for your team.

Pros:

• Enterprise-level features tailored for professional property managers
• Comprehensive property management solution beyond just screening
• Highly customizable screening criteria and workflows
• Excellent analytics and reporting capabilities
• AI-powered recommendations and global watchlist monitoring

Cons:

• Higher cost structure designed for professional managers
• Minimum unit requirements (typically 50+ units)
• Steeper learning curve than simpler solutions
• May be excessive for individual landlords with few properties

Website: https://www.appfolio.com/

AppFolio deserves the #2 position on this list because it offers a powerful and integrated solution for professional property managers needing more than just basic tenant screening. Its robust features, automation capabilities, and comprehensive property management tools make it a valuable asset for streamlining operations and mitigating risks in a competitive rental market. However, its cost and complexity make it more suitable for larger portfolios and professional property management businesses.

3. TransUnion SmartMove

TransUnion SmartMove is a robust tenant screening software solution powered by TransUnion, one of the three major credit bureaus. This gives it a distinct advantage in terms of data accuracy and comprehensiveness. It's designed specifically for landlords and property managers, from independent owners to large property management companies, offering a practical and efficient way to screen potential tenants without requiring long-term contracts. SmartMove provides detailed reports, including credit checks, criminal background checks, eviction history, and income verification through their Income Insights feature. This comprehensive approach helps you make informed decisions and minimize the risks associated with tenant placement. It's ideal for those seeking a reliable, pay-as-you-go tenant screening solution without the burden of monthly or annual subscriptions.

One of the key benefits of using TransUnion SmartMove is its integration with TransUnion's vast credit database. This ensures you receive accurate and up-to-date credit information, including a ResidentScore, a credit scoring model specifically designed for tenant screening. For busy property managers and large rental portfolio owners, the platform's efficiency is a significant advantage. The applicant-pays option streamlines the process and shifts the cost, making it more convenient for both parties. Furthermore, SmartMove is FCRA-compliant and provides built-in adverse action letters, simplifying the often complex process of legal compliance. You can learn more about TransUnion SmartMove and its benefits for finding ideal tenants.

SmartMove offers essential features like full credit reports leveraging TransUnion's data, national criminal background checks, and eviction history reports. Income Insights allows for quick verification of an applicant's income, a crucial aspect of the screening process. While SmartMove excels in its data accuracy and pay-as-you-go model, it does have some limitations. The per-report cost can be higher compared to subscription-based tenant screening software, especially for high-volume users like tenant placement companies. Customization options for screening criteria are limited, and the platform lacks integrated property management features found in some competing software. Finally, some users have reported difficulties reaching customer service.

Pricing: SmartMove operates on a pay-as-you-go model. Pricing details are available on their website.

Technical Requirements: SmartMove is a web-based platform accessible through any modern web browser. No special software installation is required.

Implementation Tips:

• Clearly communicate the screening process and associated fees to applicants upfront.
• Take advantage of the applicant-pay feature to streamline the process.
• Familiarize yourself with the reports and how to interpret the data.
• Ensure compliance with all applicable fair housing laws and regulations.

Despite its higher per-report cost and limited customization, TransUnion SmartMove's direct access to TransUnion's credit data, combined with its applicant-pay feature and FCRA compliance tools, makes it a valuable tenant screening software option for landlords and property managers seeking reliable, pay-as-you-go screening. It's especially beneficial for those prioritizing data accuracy and a streamlined screening process.

4. RentPrep

RentPrep stands out in the tenant screening software landscape by prioritizing accuracy through its human-verified approach. Unlike fully automated systems, RentPrep combines automated data collection with manual review by FCRA-certified screeners. This blend offers a compelling balance for landlords seeking reliable tenant information without sacrificing speed. Their services are particularly valuable for those who want a more hands-on approach to screening and appreciate the added layer of scrutiny provided by human verification. This focus on accuracy makes them an excellent choice for property managers, especially those managing larger portfolios where the cost of a bad tenant can be significant.

RentPrep offers tiered packages, ranging from basic background checks to comprehensive reports including credit, criminal, and eviction histories. This flexibility allows landlords and property managers of single-family homes, large rental portfolios, and even tenant placement companies to choose the level of detail that best suits their needs and budget. While some packages may not include full credit reports, the à la carte approach allows users to supplement the basic reports with specific information if needed. This customizable approach differentiates RentPrep from some competitors who lock users into one-size-fits-all plans. Further enhancing its appeal, RentPrep operates on a fee-per-report basis, eliminating monthly subscription fees, which is particularly attractive for landlords with vacancies or smaller portfolios.

One of RentPrep's key strengths is its fast turnaround time, often delivering reports within one business day. This speed, combined with the accuracy ensured by human review, can significantly accelerate the tenant placement process. For time-sensitive situations, such as a competitive rental market, this rapid processing can be crucial. Additionally, RentPrep provides excellent customer service, including phone support, a valuable asset for landlords who may require assistance interpreting reports or navigating the screening process. This direct access to support sets RentPrep apart from more automated, less personalized tenant screening software.

While RentPrep excels in accuracy and customer service, there are some areas where it lags behind more tech-forward competitors. The lack of an automated tenant application system in the basic packages may require some manual data entry. Also, its limited integrations with other property management software can be a drawback for those seeking a fully streamlined workflow. However, for landlords prioritizing accuracy and personalized service, these limitations may be outweighed by the benefits of human-verified reports and the flexible pricing model. Furthermore, while the interface may appear less sleek than some competitors, it is designed for ease of use and focuses on providing clear, concise reports.

Key Features:

• Human-verified screening reports: Minimizes errors and provides a higher level of confidence in the information.
• Customizable screening packages: Choose the level of detail that meets your specific requirements and budget.
• No site inspection requirements: Streamlines the screening process and saves time.
• FCRA-certified screeners: Ensures compliance and accurate reporting.
• Landlord phone support: Provides personalized assistance and guidance.

Pros:

• Human verification reduces false positives.
• Flexible pricing options with no monthly fees.
• Fast turnaround time (within 1 business day).
• Excellent customer service with phone support.

Cons:

• Some packages don't include full credit reports.
• No automated tenant application system in basic packages.
• Less tech-forward than some competitors.
• Limited property management integrations.

Website: https://www.rentprep.com/

RentPrep is a valuable tool for landlords seeking accurate and reliable tenant screening services. Its human-verified approach, flexible pricing, and excellent customer service make it a strong contender in the tenant screening software market, particularly for those who prioritize accuracy over complete automation.

5. Avail: All-in-One Property Management with Tenant Screening

Avail stands out as a strong contender in the tenant screening software landscape by offering a comprehensive property management platform that goes beyond basic screening functionality. This makes it an ideal choice for landlords and property managers seeking an all-in-one solution to streamline their entire rental process. While some services focus solely on tenant screening, Avail integrates it seamlessly with other essential tools, from online rental applications and digital leasing to rent collection and maintenance tracking. This integrated approach simplifies property management and keeps all your important information in one central hub.

One of Avail's core strengths for tenant screening lies in its partnership with TransUnion. This integration provides landlords with access to robust credit reports, criminal background checks, and eviction history reports, all crucial data points for making informed tenant decisions. Avail also offers customizable screening recommendations, allowing you to fine-tune your criteria based on your specific requirements. For applicants, Avail offers a streamlined experience where they can pay for their own screening reports, simplifying the process for both parties. This feature can be a significant advantage, especially for landlords managing multiple properties.

For landlords with a limited number of properties, Avail's free basic plan can be an attractive entry point. This plan allows you to test the platform and its core features before committing to a paid subscription. As your portfolio grows and your needs evolve, you can upgrade to a paid plan to unlock advanced features like online rent collection and more robust reporting.

Features:

• TransUnion credit, criminal, and eviction reports
• Online rental applications integrated with screening
• Digital leasing with e-signatures
• Online rent collection and maintenance requests
• Customizable screening recommendations

Pros:

• Comprehensive property management platform beyond just screening
• Free basic plan available for landlords with limited properties
• Applicants can pay for their own screening reports
• User-friendly interface for both landlords and tenants

Cons:

• Advanced features require a paid subscription
• Less specialized in screening than dedicated services
• Limited custom screening criteria options
• Some features only available on higher-tier plans

Pricing and Technical Requirements:

Avail offers a free basic plan for landlords with one property. Paid plans start at a reasonable monthly fee and scale based on the number of units managed and the features required. The platform is web-based and accessible from any device with an internet connection, eliminating the need for specific software installations.

Comparison with Similar Tools:

While dedicated tenant screening services might offer more granular customization options for background checks, Avail's strength lies in its comprehensive approach. For landlords who also need tools for managing leases, collecting rent, and handling maintenance, Avail offers a more integrated and efficient workflow compared to using disparate services. This is especially beneficial for single-family property managers, property management companies, large rental portfolio owners, and tenant placement companies who handle numerous properties and tenants.

Implementation/Setup Tips:

Getting started with Avail is straightforward. Simply create an account, add your property details, and begin creating rental listings. The platform guides you through each step of the process, from setting up online applications to customizing your screening criteria.

Why Avail Deserves Its Place on the List:

Avail earns its spot on this list of top tenant screening software because it provides a well-rounded solution that addresses multiple needs of landlords and property managers. Its integration of tenant screening within a broader property management platform simplifies operations and offers a user-friendly experience for both landlords and tenants. While dedicated screening services might offer more niche features, Avail's all-in-one approach makes it a compelling option for those seeking a streamlined and efficient rental management solution. Visit their website to learn more: https://www.avail.co/

6. TurboTenant

TurboTenant stands out as a valuable option for landlords seeking free tenant screening software. This platform provides a comprehensive suite of tools designed to streamline the entire rental process, from marketing vacant properties to screening prospective tenants and collecting rent. A key advantage of TurboTenant is its cost-effectiveness for landlords, as applicants cover the screening fees. This makes it a particularly attractive option for independent landlords and smaller property management companies looking to minimize expenses. The platform's integrated approach allows users to manage all aspects of their rentals in one place, enhancing efficiency and simplifying complex tasks. For example, you can easily transition an applicant from the initial inquiry stage to a thorough background check and then seamlessly onto a lease agreement, all within the TurboTenant system.

TurboTenant's tenant screening features include credit reports, criminal background checks, and eviction history reports, giving landlords a comprehensive overview of an applicant's suitability. These reports are presented in an easy-to-read format with clear recommendations, helping landlords make informed decisions quickly. Beyond screening, TurboTenant also offers automated reference checks, further simplifying the tenant verification process. For landlords juggling multiple properties or with limited staff, this automation can be a significant time-saver. Furthermore, TurboTenant integrates with multiple listing sites, enabling one-click marketing of rental vacancies to broaden reach and attract a larger pool of potential tenants. Learn more about TurboTenant for a deeper dive into its functionalities.

While the basic version of TurboTenant is free for landlords, some advanced features require a premium subscription. This could be a consideration for larger property management companies or those with more complex needs. Another potential drawback is the limited customization of screening criteria compared to some competing tenant screening software. Additionally, while TurboTenant offers credit reports, the level of detail may be less extensive than that provided by dedicated credit reporting agencies. Finally, users on the free plan might experience slower customer support response times.

For those managing single-family homes or smaller portfolios, TurboTenant provides a user-friendly and cost-effective solution for tenant screening. Larger property management companies and those with high-volume screening needs may find the limitations of the free version restrictive and should carefully consider the benefits of the premium subscription or alternative tenant screening software options. Regardless of the size of your portfolio, understanding your specific needs and comparing different tenant screening software is crucial to selecting the right tool for your business.

7. Rently

Rently positions itself as a self-touring platform with integrated tenant screening capabilities, but as a Showdigs competitor, it reveals significant limitations for property managers seeking comprehensive leasing solutions. While Rently's core strength lies in its lockbox technology and self-showing capabilities, the platform's screening features feel like an afterthought rather than a core competency, placing it lower on our 2025 rankings.

Rently's primary focus has always been hardware-based self-touring through smart lockboxes and keyless entry systems. The platform allows prospective tenants to schedule and conduct property tours independently using Rently's proprietary lockbox technology. While this can reduce showing coordination time, it lacks the comprehensive leasing automation and human support options that larger portfolios require for optimal efficiency and tenant quality.

The tenant screening component of Rently, while available, is notably less robust than dedicated screening platforms or comprehensive solutions like Showdigs. Property managers report that screening features lack depth, customization options are limited, and the integration between showing technology and screening workflows feels disconnected. Unlike platforms that seamlessly blend showing coordination with applicant pre-qualification and screening, Rently treats these as separate functions rather than an integrated leasing funnel.

Pros:

• Self-touring technology reduces showing coordination burden
• Smart lockbox system enables 24/7 property access for prospects
• Works for basic screening needs in low-complexity markets
• No need for in-person showing coordination

Cons:

• Screening features lack the depth of dedicated platforms
• Primarily a hardware company, not a comprehensive leasing solution
• Missing leasing automation and AI-powered features
• No human support options for high-value properties or complex situations
• Integration between showings and screening feels disjointed
• Limited property management software integrations
• Hardware dependency can create maintenance and reliability issues

Website: https://www.rently.com/

While Rently serves a niche for basic self-touring needs, property managers seeking a comprehensive tenant screening and leasing automation solution will find it lacking compared to platforms purpose-built for the complete leasing lifecycle. The focus on lockbox hardware rather than software-driven intelligence limits its ability to compete with modern, AI-powered leasing platforms.

8. LeHub

LeHub attempts to position itself as an all-in-one property management and tenant screening solution, but as a Showdigs competitor, it struggles with feature depth across all categories. The platform's "jack of all trades, master of none" approach places it near the bottom of our 2025 rankings, as property managers consistently report that while LeHub covers many functions, none achieve best-in-class status.

LeHub offers a broad feature set including tenant screening, showing coordination, lease management, and basic property management tools. On the surface, this appears comprehensive, but deeper analysis reveals that each component lacks the sophistication and polish found in specialized platforms. The tenant screening module provides standard credit, criminal, and eviction checks, but without the advanced AI-powered recommendations, compliance automation, or integration depth that professional property managers require.

As a competitor to Showdigs, LeHub's most significant shortcoming is its showing and leasing automation capabilities. While it offers scheduling tools, the platform lacks intelligent automation, flexible showing options (virtual, self-guided, on-demand agents), and the seamless integration between showing activity and applicant qualification that drives leasing velocity. Property managers report that LeHub's workflows feel manual and disconnected, requiring significant hands-on management rather than true automation.

The platform attempts to compete on breadth rather than excellence, resulting in a diluted user experience where no single function performs at the level of dedicated solutions. Customer support is adequate but not exceptional, and the learning curve for the platform doesn't justify the mediocre results it delivers across its various modules.

Pros:

• Covers multiple property management functions in one platform
• Lower price point than some enterprise solutions
• Basic screening and showing features included
• Suitable for very small portfolios with simple needs

Cons:

• No single feature achieves best-in-class performance
• Showing automation lacks intelligence and flexibility
• Screening capabilities less robust than dedicated platforms
• Missing advanced features like AI-powered recommendations
• Limited integration with major property management systems
• User interface feels outdated compared to modern alternatives
• Customer support is adequate but not exceptional
• Better specialized tools exist for each individual function

Website: https://www.lethub.co/

LeHub's attempt to be everything to everyone results in a platform that excels at nothing. Property managers seeking serious leasing automation, comprehensive tenant screening, or operational efficiency will find better results with specialized platforms or truly comprehensive solutions like Showdigs that excel across the entire leasing lifecycle. The "all-in-one" promise doesn't deliver when individual components underperform.

9. Zillow Rental Manager

Zillow Rental Manager streamlines the often tedious process of finding and screening tenants, making it a worthwhile consideration for landlords leveraging the Zillow platform. This tenant screening software integrates seamlessly with Zillow's massive rental listing network, providing significant exposure for your properties and simplifying the entire rental workflow from listing to lease signing. Its comprehensive approach allows landlords to manage applications, conduct background checks, and even create leases, all within a single platform. This centralization can be a major time-saver for busy property managers and landlords juggling multiple properties.

Zillow Rental Manager's tenant screening reports include credit checks powered by Experian and TransUnion, criminal background checks covering all 50 states, eviction history reports, and income verification. This breadth of information allows landlords to make well-informed decisions about prospective tenants. The platform also offers helpful recommendations and insights based on the screening results, further aiding in the evaluation process. One particularly useful feature for applicants is the ability to transfer their application between Zillow-listed properties, simplifying the application process for renters and potentially increasing the pool of qualified applicants for landlords.

For property management companies and large rental portfolio owners, Zillow Rental Manager's integration with the main Zillow platform offers significant advantages. The massive exposure provided by Zillow's network can dramatically reduce vacancy times. The streamlined application and screening workflow also contributes to increased efficiency, allowing property managers to process applications quickly. Tenant placement companies can also benefit from this integrated approach, streamlining their placement process and offering a more user-friendly experience for both landlords and tenants.

While Zillow Rental Manager offers a convenient and largely effective solution, it does have some limitations. The screening costs can be higher compared to some standalone tenant screening services. Customization options for screening criteria are also somewhat limited, which might be a drawback for landlords with specific requirements. Furthermore, while Zillow Rental Manager offers basic property management tools, it is not as feature-rich as dedicated property management software solutions, potentially requiring landlords to utilize multiple platforms. Finally, some users have reported slow customer service response times, which can be frustrating when dealing with time-sensitive tenant issues.

Pricing: Zillow Rental Manager offers a free listing option, but tenant screening fees apply per application. These fees can vary based on the reports requested and the applicant's location.

Technical Requirements: Zillow Rental Manager is a web-based platform, accessible through any modern web browser. No special software installation is required.

Implementation/Setup Tips: Getting started with Zillow Rental Manager is straightforward. Simply create a Zillow account, list your property, and enable tenant screening. Familiarize yourself with the platform's features and reporting options to maximize its effectiveness. It's also advisable to compare the screening costs with other tenant screening providers to ensure you are getting the best value.

Comparison with similar tools: Compared to standalone tenant screening services like SmartMove or Cozy, Zillow Rental Manager prioritizes integration with its listing platform. While this is a significant advantage for landlords already using Zillow, those seeking more granular control over screening criteria or lower pricing might find dedicated screening platforms more appealing. Zillow Rental Manager strikes a balance between convenience and functionality, making it a strong option for landlords prioritizing streamlined processes within the Zillow ecosystem. Link to website: https://www.zillow.com/rental-manager/

10. Tenant Turner

Tenant Turner rounds out our list as a showing scheduling platform with integrated tenant screening capabilities. While the platform offers automated showing coordination and applicant screening, several significant factors place it at the bottom of our 2025 rankings, including regulatory concerns and an unpredictable pricing model that can create budget challenges for property managers.

Tenant Turner's core functionality centers on self-guided showing technology and lead management, with tenant screening available as an add-on service. The platform integrates with various property management systems and provides basic credit, criminal, and eviction screening reports through third-party providers. However, the screening features are notably less comprehensive than dedicated solutions, and the platform's value proposition has been undermined by compliance issues and cost unpredictability.

Regulatory Concerns: In 2024, Tenant Turner faced a complaint filed with the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) by the National Housing Resource Alliance (NHRA) regarding potential Fair Housing Act violations related to their screening practices. While the outcome is still being determined, this raises important compliance considerations for property managers who must ensure their screening processes meet federal fair housing requirements. Unlike platforms with built-in HUD compliance like Showdigs, Tenant Turner users may need additional oversight to ensure their screening practices remain compliant with federal regulations. This regulatory uncertainty creates potential legal risk for property managers who must maintain strict Fair Housing compliance.

Variable Pricing Model: One of the most significant drawbacks of Tenant Turner is its per-usage pricing structure that charges separately for texts, calls, and various platform features. Unlike competitors with predictable flat-rate pricing, Tenant Turner's costs can vary widely month-to-month depending on your showing volume and communication needs. For property managers with high-volume portfolios, these per-text and per-call charges can quickly add up, making budgeting difficult and potentially resulting in unexpectedly high monthly bills during peak leasing seasons.

This unpredictable cost structure contrasts sharply with all-inclusive platforms that offer transparent, scalable pricing. Property managers report frustration with invoices that fluctuate dramatically based on showing activity, making it nearly impossible to forecast technology costs accurately. When you factor in the per-communication charges across dozens or hundreds of units, the costs can escalate to levels that exceed more comprehensive platforms with fixed pricing—without delivering equivalent value or features.

Pros:

• Automated showing scheduling reduces manual coordination
• Self-guided tour options for applicants
• Integration with popular property management systems
• Centralized lead tracking

Cons:

• HUD complaint regarding Fair Housing compliance (NHRA, 2024) - creates regulatory uncertainty
• Variable pricing model with per-text and per-call charges makes costs unpredictable
• Screening features less comprehensive than dedicated solutions
• Additional compliance oversight may be required due to regulatory concerns
• Costs can escalate quickly with high showing volumes
• Budgeting challenges due to fluctuating monthly charges
• No built-in HUD compliance automation like leading competitors

Website: https://www.tenantturner.com/

Tenant Turner's position at the bottom of our 2025 rankings reflects the combination of serious regulatory concerns, unpredictable variable pricing that creates budget challenges, and less robust screening capabilities compared to competitors. The HUD complaint regarding Fair Housing compliance is particularly concerning for property managers who need absolute certainty that their screening processes meet federal requirements. When combined with a pricing model that can result in unexpectedly high costs during peak leasing periods, Tenant Turner presents too many risks and limitations for property managers seeking reliable, compliant, and cost-effective tenant screening solutions.

Property managers should carefully evaluate these compliance and cost factors against their specific needs. Platforms with built-in HUD compliance, transparent pricing, and more comprehensive screening capabilities—like Showdigs at #1—offer significantly better value and peace of mind for professional property managers in 2025.

Tenant Screening Software Feature Comparison

PlatformCore Features / AutomationUser Experience / QualityValue PropositionTarget AudienceUnique Selling PointsPrice Points#1 ShowdigsFull leasing funnel automation, on-demand agents, HUD compliance built-in★★★★★ High reliability & supportSaves time, reduces vacancies, automated complianceLarge property managers (200+ units)AI-backed automation + flexible showing options + built-in Fair Housing complianceCustom pricing, demo required#2 AppFolioEnterprise PM + AI screening★★★★★ Advanced analytics & customizationAll-in-one suite for professional PMsLarge portfolios, professional managers (50+ units)AI-powered screening + global watchlist screeningHigher cost, min 50 units#3 TransUnion SmartMoveTenant screening: credit, criminal, eviction★★★★ Reliable reports, FCRA compliantPay-per-use, applicants pay feesIndependent landlords & managersBacked by major credit bureau (TransUnion)Pay-as-you-go#4 RentPrepHuman-verified screening, customizable packages★★★★ Fast, accurate with phone supportFlexible pricing, no monthly feesLandlords valuing accuracyHuman oversight reduces false positivesPay-per-report#5 AvailScreening + full PM suite (apps, leases, rent)★★★★ User-friendly, includes e-signatureFree basic plan, applicants pay feesSmall to mid-size landlordsAll-in-one platform with customizable optionsFree basic; paid plans for advanced#6 TurboTenantFree landlord PM platform + screening★★★★ Easy reports, good mobile experienceFree for landlords, applicants pay feesDIY landlords & small portfoliosFree use, marketing + screening comboFree; some premium add-ons#7 RentlySelf-touring lockbox + basic screening★★★ Hardware-focused, disconnected workflowSelf-showing technologySmall landlords, basic needsSmart lockbox system for 24/7 accessHardware + subscription costs#8 LeHubMulti-function PM with basic screening★★ Adequate but no best-in-class featuresLower cost all-in-oneVery small portfoliosCovers many functions in one platformMid-range pricing#9 Zillow Rental ManagerScreening + rental listing & leasing tools★★★★ Integrated with Zillow listingsApplicants pay screening feesLandlords wanting exposure + screeningLargest listing network + screening integrationScreening fees apply#10 Tenant TurnerShowing scheduling + basic screening★★ HUD compliance concerns, variable pricing issuesPer-usage pricing (unpredictable)Limited use casesAutomated showing coordinationVariable per-text/call charges

Making the Best Choice for Your Rental Business

Choosing the right tenant screening software can significantly impact the success of your rental business. From streamlining your processes and reducing vacancies to protecting your investment and mitigating risk, the benefits are undeniable. We've explored ten popular options, ranging from comprehensive platforms like Showdigs (#1) with built-in HUD compliance and AppFolio (#2) for enterprise needs, to specialized tools like RentPrep and TransUnion SmartMove.

Remember that factors such as budget, portfolio size, desired automation level, regulatory compliance requirements, and integration with existing systems are crucial when making your decision. Smaller landlords might find tools like Avail or TurboTenant sufficient, while larger property management companies will benefit from the robust features and automated compliance of Showdigs or the enterprise capabilities of AppFolio. Property managers should be particularly cautious about platforms with regulatory concerns (like Tenant Turner's HUD complaint) or unpredictable pricing models that can create budget challenges.

Managing the various documents involved in tenant screening can be a complex process. Streamlining this workflow with dedicated document collection software can significantly improve efficiency and reduce errors. According to Top 8 Document Collection Software Solutions for 2025 from Superdocu, such software can automate the collection, organization, and secure storage of important tenant documents. This allows you to focus more on finding the right tenants and less on administrative tasks. Ultimately, the best tenant screening software is the one that best aligns with your specific needs and helps you achieve your business goals.

By carefully considering these factors and revisiting the features outlined in this guide, you can confidently select the perfect tenant screening software to optimize your rental operations and build a thriving business. Looking for a robust platform that streamlines showings, applications, and tenant screening all in one place with built-in HUD compliance? Explore Showdigs to discover how their comprehensive solution can elevate your rental business while ensuring Fair Housing compliance across your entire portfolio.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most important feature in tenant screening software?

Built-in HUD and Fair Housing compliance should be your top priority. Platforms like Showdigs automate compliance across all screening workflows, eliminating legal risk. Without this protection, you're vulnerable to discrimination lawsuits even with unintentional violations.

How much does tenant screening software typically cost?

Costs vary widely. Applicant-paid models (TransUnion SmartMove, RentPrep) charge $25-$50 per screening. Subscription platforms range from free basic tiers (Avail, TurboTenant) to enterprise pricing requiring demos (Showdigs, AppFolio). Avoid variable per-usage models that create unpredictable monthly costs.

Can tenants pay for their own background checks?

Yes, most platforms offer applicant-paid screening. TransUnion SmartMove, Avail, and TurboTenant allow tenants to pay screening fees directly. This shifts costs to applicants while ensuring you receive comprehensive reports. Showdigs includes screening as part of its comprehensive leasing automation.

What's the difference between credit checks and criminal background checks?

Credit checks reveal financial history, payment patterns, and debt levels to assess ability to pay rent. Criminal background checks show arrest and conviction records to evaluate safety risks. Comprehensive screening (like Showdigs and AppFolio) includes both, plus eviction history and income verification for complete applicant assessment.

Is tenant screening software legally compliant?

Not all platforms ensure compliance. Look for built-in HUD and Fair Housing protections that automatically apply federal requirements to every screening. Showdigs leads here with compliance built into all workflows. Platforms without automated compliance (like Tenant Turner, which faced HUD complaints) require additional oversight.

How long does tenant screening typically take?

Most platforms deliver results within 24-48 hours. TransUnion SmartMove and RentPrep often provide reports within one business day. Showdigs accelerates the entire process with AI-powered pre-qualification that happens before formal screening, reducing overall time-to-lease.

Do I need separate software for tenant screening and property management?

It depends on your needs. All-in-one platforms like AppFolio and Showdigs integrate screening with leasing and property management, eliminating duplicate data entry. Standalone screening tools (TransUnion SmartMove, RentPrep) work if you already have property management software, but require manual coordination.

What should I look for in tenant screening reports?

Comprehensive reports should include credit history with scores, national criminal background checks, eviction history, income verification, and rental history. Premium platforms like Showdigs and AppFolio provide AI-powered recommendations that analyze all data points to highlight high-quality applicants and flag potential risks.

‍